Clear about what the evidence shows, and what it does not.

Evidence you can stand behind

When a decision depends on a report, proposal, strategy, public claim, or funding case, you need to know where the record is strong and where it is not. Jim helps leaders trace important claims to their sources, test the reasoning, and make unresolved limits visible before the work reaches a board, funder, regulator, partner, or the public.

(Talk with Jim)

When the claim matters

The biggest problems are often ordinary ones: a source no one can reopen, a claim that grew stronger with each revision, or a review process that left important questions unasked. Any of these can undermine a funding decision, policy position, partnership, public statement, or implementation plan. The Evidence Integrity Process separates the work of finding sources, verifying them, interpreting them, and approving the final conclusion, so another qualified reviewer can follow the reasoning and see where judgment or uncertainty remains.

A practical first step

The Room Test

Two-week engagement; fees start at $15,000.

Every important case eventually enters a room: a board meeting, a funding committee, a hearing, or a negotiation. The Room Test puts the case through that scrutiny early, while there is still time to strengthen it.

The Room Test is led by Jim, with senior specialists in intellectual property, science, and public policy brought in when the work requires their judgment.

How it runs

  1. Frame the decision. A working session establishes what you are bringing, the decision it must support, who will evaluate it, and where you expect the hardest questions.
  2. Test the case. Jim traces key claims to their sources, examines the assumptions beneath them, and challenges the case the way the room will. Specialists join at the points where their judgment matters.
  3. Deliver the Decision Brief. You leave with a written brief and a live session on how to use it.

What you receive

The Decision Brief

The engagement ends with a plain-language brief you can share with the people who will sign off.

  • The agreed scope and evidence cutoff, in writing
  • An executive summary of findings
  • The evidence boundary: what the record supports and where it stops
  • The questions the current evidence can answer, and the ones that remain open
  • Specialist observations, when specialist review is part of the scope
  • A prioritized repair plan
  • A live briefing on the findings and how to use them

The final scope and fee depend on the number of reports, source volume, systems involved, and any specialist review the work requires.

How the review works

The Room Test uses the same Evidence Integrity method Jim brings to larger engagements.

Agree on the question, scope, and evidence cutoff.
Decide what counts as evidence.
Separate the source record from interpretation.
Review important claims and resolve disagreements.
Release conclusions with limits and open questions visible.

If you need a repeatable process

Build it into the work

Jim can adapt the evidence ledger, source rules, review gates, operating procedures, templates, and training to fit your team.

Keep the process honest

Ongoing support can include source audits, independent review, adjudication, and release checks. When possible, the reviewer is someone other than the person who made the claim; conflicts and practical limits are documented.

Train a team

Training and organization-wide use are scoped around the team and its systems. Formal certification is not offered and would be considered only after independent validation.

Who it is for

This work is for leaders whose reports, proposals, strategies, or funding cases must hold up before boards, funders, regulators, partners, or the public.

Health and public-health organizations
Public-benefit and policy organizations
Foundations and philanthropic organizations
Research and evaluation teams

What this work can and cannot do

The process is designed to reduce unsupported, overstated, or irreproducible findings, but no review can guarantee that every relevant source or every error will be found. Each engagement states what is in scope, when the evidence record closes, what access and specialist review are available, and how far the conclusions can reasonably go. Pine Lake Policy Group provides evidence review and decision support, not legal, patent, clinical, investment, or other regulated professional advice. Specialists contribute technical observations within the agreed scope; their involvement does not turn the work into regulated professional advice.

Start with one piece of work

Bring one important claim, report, or funding case

Choose the report, proposal, strategy, public claim, or funding case that matters most right now, along with the decision it needs to support. The Room Test will show what the evidence can support, where the case is vulnerable, and what should happen before it enters the room.

(Contact Jim)